Pros and Cons of Personality Tests in Hiring Process - Tilson


Pros and Cons of Personality Tests in Hiring Process

Hiring & Onboarding | July 2021

Personality tests are questionnaires designed to reveal aspects of an individual’s character. As many as 60 percent of workers are asked to complete these tests as part of the hiring process.

While many companies use personality tests for career development, 22 percent of employers use them to assess candidates’ personality traits (for example, persuasiveness, detail orientation and conscientiousness) during the hiring process. There are thousands of  tests available, but the quality of these tests varies along with the potential legal risks associated with them.

Benefits of Personality Tests

The following are the benefits of using such tests in the workplace:

  • Better placement. They can help identify individuals who may excel at certain jobs. For example, those who score high in empathy may do well at jobs in customer service.
  • Strengthen the interview. When coupled with a good interview, personality-tests can help you gain more insight into candidates’ abilities.

Drawbacks of Personality Tests

There are many disadvantages, though, in the workplace.

  • It may screen out qualified candidates. For many jobs, there isn’t a mainstream personality that fits the job type. Such tests may also exclude talented candidates who think outside the box.
  • It may cause flawed results. Candidates may respond based on what they think the employer wants rather than on their true personalities; therefore, results aren’t always accurate.
  • The purpose of the test may not fit into your hiring process. Many of today’s most popular tests were not designed to be used in the hiring process. For example, the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator was created for career development and training, not for hiring. Therefore, using it in the hiring process can lead to skewed results.
  • There may be legal risks. Such tests can result in claims of discrimination. Some individuals have successfully sued employers on the grounds that their test discriminated against individuals with mental illnesses and violated the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). For example, questions such as, “Over the course of the day, do you experience many mood changes?” could discriminate against individuals with bipolar disorder or depression. Including questions like this on your company’s personality test could open the door for future lawsuits.

Subscribe to our HR Insights and receive weekly tips on HR topics.

What Can Employers Do

In order to mitigate your legal risk, consider taking the steps below:

  • Measure your test’s validity. Make sure your personality test is a valid predictor of job performance and has a high reliability, meaning that it will produce the same results if the same person takes it twice. Tests should measure traits that will remain stable over time.
  • Conduct an internal analysis of your personality test with the help of legal counsel to determine any risks.
  • Review current and previous Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) lawsuits regarding personality tests and remove any questions that have been viewed as discriminatory.
  • Make sure personality tests are just a component of the hiring process. Do not allow results from personality tests alone to exclude a candidate.

Download our free e-guide on Interviewing Job Candidates

For more information on hiring check out our resource center, or  contact Tilson HR today.

Check out more HR Insights.





Press Releases

More resources

Sign up for HR insights from the Tilson team.

Skip to content